Idaho said in When did people stop using common sense?:
The problem with dedis is not only on how poorly admins manage their population but also in the way they're configured, no map rotation, stupid time or score limits, unnecessary high player counts, all servers have 18 players when most maps can't handle that, the list goes on and on...
I am not saying you don't have a point here but everything you listed is possible with lobbies as well. And not all servers are configured like that.
Idaho said in When did people stop using common sense?:
With matchmaking you have at least the possibility of enjoying the vanilla game, so yeah from time to time a kid would ruin the lobby with stupid scripts but it's something that even happens on PS3 and 360, you just leave the lobby and get matched again
You can do the same with dedicated servers and blacklist them.